Home The Firm Lawyer Bios Students Zone Resources Disputes Between Insurers Careers Contact
 
  Disputes Between Insurers

The following is a collection of priority dispute and loss transfer decisions. The collection also includes authorities relevant to disputes between insurers. (e.g. cases interpreting the meaning of spouse).

This collection includes decisions by Craig Brown, Jonathan Fidler, Guy Jones, Stephen Malach, Bruce Robinson, Jay Rudolph, Ken Bialkowski, Stan Tessis, and Lee Samis.

Recently Added:

ING v. Chubb (Tessis, DOL: 5/28/02) View the Decision

Decisions

Allstate v. Allianz (Samis, DOL: 08/04/03) View the Decision

Allstate v. Axa Boreal (Robinson, DOL: 12/15/95) View the Decision

Allstate v. Boreal (Samis, DOL: 06/21/94) View the Decision

Allstate v. CGU (Webb, DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Allstate v. Liberty (Samis, DOL: 03/05/95) View the Decision

Allstate v. Old Republic (Griffiths, DOL: 10/30/94) View the Decision

Allstate v. Old Republic (Robinson, DOL: 09/15/96) View the Decision

Allstate v. State Farm (Malach, DOL: 07/05/03) View the Decision

American Home v. Axa (MacPherson, DOL: 10/26/94) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

American Home v. Halifax (Jones, DOL: 12/03/99) View the Decision

Aviva v. Lombard (Jones, DOL: 10/01/98) View the Decision

Aviva v. Lombard and Liberty (Malach, DOL: 09/02/00) View the Decision

Axa v. Belair Direct (Application: Superior Court, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Axa v. Belair Direct (Bialkowski, DOL: 10/22/01) View the Decision

Axa v. Co-operators (Rudolph, DOL: 02/20/96) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court Decision Unavailable

Axa v. Gore and State Farm (Malach, DOL: 08/23/98) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Axa v. ING (Samis, DOL: 5/24/03) View the Decision

Axa v Markel (Fidler, DOL: 01/30/96) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Axa v Markel (Fidler, DOL: 06/14/95) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Axa v Old Republic (Galligan, DOL: 08/01/95) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Axa v Pilot (Malach, DOL: 05/15/99) View the Decision

Axa v Prince (Court of Appeal, DOL: 08/30/95) View the Decision

Axa v. Royal (Robinson, DOL: 10/13/95) View the Decision

Axa Boreal v. Co-operators (Robinson, DOL: 12/20/95) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Boreal v. Dominion (Motion: General Division, DOL: 09/20/90) View the Decision

Brown v. Allstate (Collier, DOL: 09/02/96) View the Decision
Appeal of related proceeding: General Division View the Decision

Canada Life v. Progressive (Samis, DOL: 10/08/94) View the Decision

Canadian General v. Axa (Malach, DOL: 08/29/95) View the Decision

Canadian General v Axa (Galligan, DOL: 12/14/93) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Canadian General v. Jevco (Motion: General Division, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Certas v. Allstate (Malach, DOL: 02/01/03) View the Decision

Certas v. CGU/Aviva (Samis, DOL: 09/23/02) View the Decision

CGU v. Canada Life and Liberty (Jones, DOL: 04/29/98) View the Decision

CGU v. Lombard (Jones, DOL: 05/07/99) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

CGU v. Zurich (Jones, DOL: 08/03/98) View the Decision

Citadel v. Pembridge (Samis, DOL: 08/02) View the Decision

Coachman v. The Personal (Malach, DOL: 01/05/01) View the Decision

Cooperators v. State Farm (Robinson, DOL: 06/05/92) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Allstate (Robinson, DOL: 07/29/98) View the Decision

Co-operators v. Canadian General (Hudson, DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Cooperators v. Cigna (Robinson, DOL: 08/23/96) View the Decision
Appeal: Divisional Court View the Decision

Cooperators v. Cigna (Samis, DOL: 07/20/95) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Economical (Jones, DOL: 08/11/02) View the Decision

Cooperators v. General Accident (Robinson, DOL: 10/06/93) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Gore (Robinson, DOL: 08/03/00) View the Decision

Co-operators v. ING (Samis, DOL: 12/09/01) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Kingsway (Robinson, DOL: 05/04/95) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Lloyds (Jones, DOL: 08/19/00) View the Decision
Appeal: Affirmed: Decision of Msbur, J., dated November 27, 2002.

Cooperators v. Ontario (Jones, DOL: 05/21/99) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Royal (Samis, DOL: 12/12/94) View the Decision

Cooperators v. Royal (Montgomery, DOL: 03/11/93) View the Decision

Cooperators v. State Farm (Robinson, DOL: 12/11/99) View the Decision

Cooperators v. The Halifax (Samis, DOL: 10/09/98) View the Decision

Cooperators v. State Farm and Dominion (Robinson, DOL: 12/11/99) View the Decision

Coseco v. Allstate (Malach, DOL: 05/29/99) View the Decision

Coseco v. Lombard (Jones, DOL: 04/18/01) View the Decision

CT Direct v. Liberty (Jones, DOL: 11/16/98) View the Decision

Dominion v. Cooperators (Malach, DOL: 03/20/97) View the Decision

Dominion v. General Accident (Flannigan, DOL: 02/04/96) View the Decision

Dominion v. Kingsway (Samis, DOL: 10/05/97) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Dominion v. Ontario (Samis, DOL: 01/01/96) View the Decision

Dominion v. Royal & SunAlliance (Malach, DOL: 05/24/94) View the Decision

Dominion v. Wawanesa (Samis, DOL: 07/22/98) View the Decision

Dominion v. Zurch (Malach, DOL: 07/26/95) View the Decision

Dominion v. Zurich (Robinson, DOL: 08/04/97) View the Decision

Economical v. American Home (Brown, DOL: 12/00) View the Decision

Economical v. Aviva (Robinson, DOL: 11/27/00) View the Decision

Economical v. Belair Direct (Samis, DOL: 10/10/04) View the Decision

Economical v. ICBC (Jones, DOL: 07/11/98) View the Decision

Economical v. Lott (General Division, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division, Supplement View the Decision

Economical v. State Farm (Robinson, DOL: 12/25/99) View the Decision

Economical v. Wawanesa (Robinson, DOL: 02/25/02) View the Decision

Economical v. Wawanesa (Robinson, DOL: 07/01/00) View the Decision

Farmers v. Cigna (Malach, DOL: 08/29/94) View the Decision

Federated v CGU (Malach, DOL: 07/06/01) View the Decision

Federation v. Liberty (Samis, DOL: 02/13/98) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

GAN v. State Farm (DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

General Accident v. London Guarantee (Robinson, DOL: 02/24/95) View the Decision

Guardian v. Wawanesa (Malach, DOL: 10/19/96) View the Decision

Halifax v. Certas Direct (Malach, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Hartford v. Cooperators (Robinson, DOL: 12/13/99) View the Decision

Herrera v. Wawanesa (OIC, DOL: 12/01/93) View the Decision

ICBC v. Royal (Application: Superior Court, DOL: 12/24/93) View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

ING v. Chubb (Tessis, DOL: 5/28/02) View the Decision

ING v. Cooperators (Robinson, DOL: 09/01/02) View the Decision

ING Halifax v. Liberty Mutual (Malach, DOL: 01/19/96) View the Decision

ING Halifax v. Royal & SunAlliance (Superior Court, DOL: 02/15/95) View the Decision

ING Halifax v. Travellers (Robinson, DOL: 11/21/97) View the Decision

ING v. Lloyds (Samis, DOL: 05/29/01) View the Decision

ING v. Royal & SunAlliance (Robinson, DOL: 08/23/01) View the Decision

Jackson v. Dennis (General Division, DOL: 01/13/89) View the Decision

Jager v. Liberty Mutual (Alberta Court of Appeal, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Jevco v. Axa (Robinson, DOL: 11/19/94) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court Decision Unavailable

Jevco v. Axa (Malach, DOL: 10/01/92) View the Decision

Jevco v. Canadian General (Application, Superior Court, DOL: 09/01/90) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Jevco v. Canadian Home (DOL: 1990) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Jevco v. Commercial Union (Application: General Division, DOL: 10/05/92) View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Jevco v. Continental (Application, Superior Court, DOL: 10/09/91) View the Decision

Jevco v. Dominion (General Division, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Jevco v. Dominion (Holland, DOL: 10/30/90) View the Decision

Jevco v. Guardian (Malach, DOL: 10/07/93) View the Decision
Preliminary Issue: Malach View the Decision
Appeal Preliminary Issue: Superior Court View the Decision
Costs: Malach View the Decision

Jevco v. Halifax (DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Jevco v. Maplex (Robinson, DOL: 07/17/94) View the Decision
Appeal: Robinson View the Decision

Jevco v. Pilot (Montgomery, DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Jevco v. Pilot (Montgomery, DOL: 02/19/95) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Jevco v. Prudential (Ayers, DOL: 12/03/90) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division View the Decision
Motion: General Division View the Decision

Jevco v. Royal (Campbell, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Jevco v. Wawanesa (Ayers, DOL: 06/08/94) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Jevco v. York Fire (Wesley, DOL: 02/28/91) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Kalinkine v. Ontario (Application: Superior Court, DOL: 01/03/00) View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Kamstra v. Allstate and State Farm (Rudolph, DOL: 11/26/95) View the Decision

Kingsway v. Guardian (Robinson, DOL: 10/22/97) View the Decision

Lewandowska v. GAN Canada (General Division, DOL: 07/17/93) View the Decision

Liberty v. AI Transport (Robinson, DOL: 02/02/01) View the Decision

Liberty v. Commerce (Jones, DOL: 08/03/96) View the Decision
Appeal: View the Decision

Liberty v. Hartford (Jones, DOL: 06/07/94) View the Decision

Lloyds v. Guarantee (Montgomery, DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision
Interest: General Division View the Decision

Lloyds v. State Farm (Robinson, DOL: 01/03/97) View the Decision

Lloyds v. Wawanesa (Jones, DOL: 03/09/01) View the Decision

Lombard v. Allstate (Malach, DOL: 09/14/97) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Lombard v. Royal & SunAlliance (Malach, DOL: 11/17/97) View the Decision

Lumbermens v. Lombard (Malach, DOL: 03/03/96) View the Decision

Monette v. Old Republic (Superior Court, DOL: 01/05/93) View the Decision

Monnex v. Belair (Malach, DOL: 04/08/95) View the Decision

Morton v. Rabito (Court of Appeal, DOL: 01/93) View the Decision

Motors v. Cooperators (Jones, DOL: 08/18/02) View the Decision

Motors v. Coachman (Jones, DOL: 01/22/01) View the Decision

National Frontier v. Royal (Robinson, DOL: 11/02/95) View the Decision

National Frontier v. Pilot (Malach, DOL: 07/24/98) View the Decision

OMEX v. Liberty (Jones, DOL: 07/14/97) View the Decision

Ontario v. CGU (Robinson, DOL: 01/08/98) View the Decision

Ontario v. Cooperators (Robinson, DOL: 11/08/99) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Ontario v. ING Halifax (DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Ontario v. Kingsway (Robinson, DOL: 04/01/00) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Ontario v. Royal & SunAlliance et al (Jones, DOL: 08/11/99) View the Decision

Optimum Fronteir v. ING Halifax (Jones, DOL: 01/09/01) View the Decision

Oxford Mutual v. Cooperators (Jones, DOL: 07/07/02) View the Decision

Panou v. Zurich (FSCO, DOL: 09/17/95) View the Decision

Pembridge v. Liberty et al (Robinson, DOL: 01/28/99) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Pilot v. Lombard (Malach, DOL: 07/20/96) View the Decision

Pilot v. State Farm (Malach, DOL: 07/30/02) View the Decision

Primmum v. Allstate (Jones, DOL: 05/20/01) View the Decision

Primmum v. Aviva (Parnega, DOL: 09/11/98) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Primmum v. Royal & SunAlliance (Robinson, DOL: 06/23/01) View the Decision

Progressive v. Coseco (Silver, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Progressive v. Jevco (Holland, DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Progressive v. Markel (Malach, DOL: 01/14/93) View the Decision

Progressive v. State Farm (Robinson, DOL: 10/07/96) View the Decision

Progressive v. Zurich (Samis, DOL: 01/13/93) View the Decision

RBC v. Lloyds (Robinson, DOL: 10/05/00) View the Decision

RBC v. Lombard (Jones, DOL: 10/29/00) View the Decision

Riesner v. Liao (General Division, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Royal & SunAlliance v. Axa (Robinson, DOL: 08/20/94) View the Decision

Royal & SunAlliance v. State Farm (Bialkowski, DOL: 06/16/99) View the Decision

Royal v. Canadian Surety (Malach, DOL: 11/07/94) View the Decision

Royal v. Wawanesa (O’Brien, DOL: 12/05/94) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision
Leave to Appeal: Court of Appeal Granted

Saskatchewan Government Insurance v. Lombard and Ontario (Robinson, DOL: 06/17/97) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision
Subsequent Decision: Saskatchewan Government Insurance v. Lombard (Robinson) View the Decision

Schneider v. Maahs (Court of Appeal, DOL: 01/25/97) View the Decision

State Farm v. Dominion and Royal & SunAlliance (Bialkowski, DOL: 06/16/99) View the Decision

State Farm v. Lloyds et al (Jones, DOL: 06/11/99) View the Decision

State Farm v. Canadian Surety (Malach, DOL: 03/08/95) View the Decision

State_Farm v. CGU (Fidler, DOL: 08/22/96) View the Decision

State Farm v. Continental and Glens Falls (Robinson, DOL: 12/27/95) View the Decision

State Farm v. Cooperators (Brown, DOL: 11/02/00) View the Decision

State Farm v. Dominion (Jones, DOL: 03/10/92) View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

State Farm v. ING (Brown, DOL: 07/22/99) View the Decision

State Farm v. Kingsway (Samis, DOL: 03/23/98) View the Decision

State Farm v. Lloyds (DOL: Unknown) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

State Farm v. Ontario and Geig (Jones, DOL: 06/13/97) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

State Farm v. Pilot (Malach, DOL: 02/14/95) View the Decision

State Farm v. Progressive (Malach, DOL: 04/03/93) View the Decision

The Personal v. Security National (Samis, DOL: 12/23/94) View the Decision
Appeal: General Division View the Decision

Travel Insurance Coordinators v. ING Halifax (Superior Court, DOL: 08/99) View the Decision

Travelers Casualty v. Guardian (Malach, DOL: 05/11/97) View the Decision
Preliminary Issue: Malach View the Decision

TTC v. Gore Mutual (Robinson, DOL: 08/15/96) View the Decision

Unifund v. Commercial Union (Robinson, DOL: 10/30/97) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

Unifund v. ICBC (Superior Court, DOL: 08/16/95) View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision
Appeal: Supreme Court View the Decision

Warwick v. Gore Mutual (General Division, DOL: 08/31/90) View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

Wawanesa v. Cooperators (Malach, DOL: 07/18/00) View the Decision

Wawanesa v. Hartford (Jones, DOL: 12/08/00) View the Decision

Wawanesa v. Kingsway (Malach, DOL: 01/09/97) View the Decision

Wawanesa v. Kingsway (Jones, DOL: 05/15/03) View the Decision

West Wawanosh v. Kingsway (Malach, DOL: 07/02/98) View the Decision
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision
Appeal: Court of Appeal View the Decision

York Fire v. Cooperators (Holland, DOL: 07/19/90) Decision Unavailable
Appeal: Superior Court View the Decision

York Fire v. Economical (Jones, DOL: 01/06/98) View the Decision

York Fire v. Royal & SunAlliance (Malach, DOL: Unknown) View the Decision

Zurich v. Pilot and Royal & SunAlliance (Malach, DOL: 11/10/96) View the Decision

© 2008 Samis & Company